Jan, 2010 – Exploring the sale of your Insurance Wholesale Brokerage
THE BELOW ARTICLE WAS PRINTED IN THE JANUARY, 2010 ROUGH NOTES MAGAZINE
AGENCY FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT
EXPLORING THE SALE OF YOUR WHOLESALER
The acquisitions market is not robust, but it’s improving
By Allen M. Go, CFA
If you are an MGA, MGU, or program administrator owner, the thought might have run
across your mind as to what options would be out there if you were to sell your firm. We are
constantly being asked about the current merger and acquisition (M&A) environment.
Whether you are interested in exploring a sale now or 10 years down the road, it helps to
understand who the acquirers are and what their appetites are for MGAs, MGUs, and
program administrators. We will take you behind the scenes as we discuss what acquirers
are looking for in an ideal acquisition.
The past year has been a tumultuous one, to say the least, for the United States economy.
Faced with the prospect of a complete collapse of the financial system about a year ago,
the economy has come off of life support and is making its way towards recovery. The
turmoil of late 2008 caused both acquirers and sellers to head for the sidelines and take a
wait-and-see attitude. Although the current environment can still be characterized as
sluggish at best, acquirers are becoming more confident as the stock market continues its
ascent from the March 2009 lows.
M&A activity has been down markedly compared to prior years. The difference in the bidask spread (i.e., seller expectations vs. the bids that buyers were comfortable putting in)
has put a damper on deals being completed. The tightening availability of credit also has
hamstrung certain acquirers—such as private equity firms—in their quest to make
acquisitions. That stated, more deals are entering the pipeline as acquirers and sellers
resume talks that were put on the back burner last year.
Turning our focus to who is buying, we segment acquirers into the following groups:
• Publicly traded brokers: Firms such as Arthur J. Gallagher and Brown & Brown, which
have significant wholesale and MGA operations, continue to be acquisitive. As they are
publicly traded on the stock market, they have easier access to capital and, in turn, to fund
• Private equity backed entities: Firms such as AmWINS Group (backed by Parthenon
Capital), Fortegra Financial (backed by Summit Partners), Swett & Crawford (backed by HM
Capital Partners), Strongwood Insurance Holdings (backed by CCMP Capital) and
Arrowhead General Insurance Agency (backed by Spectrum Equity Investors) have
expressed interest in making acquisitions within the MGA and program administrator space.
Having the support of a private equity firm provides the financial backstop needed to grow
• Insurance companies: Certain carriers are also interested in acquiring MGUs and
program administrators in order to bring these capabilities in-house and achieve cost
synergies. An example is Ironshore, which teamed up with Rockwood Programs, to acquire
Wright & Co., a program administrator focused on the professional liability market.*
• Privately held MGAs and wholesalers: These companies also present an alternative
avenue when you are exploring a sale of your firm. An acquirer fitting this bill is Southwest
Insurance Partners which purchased Southwest Risk, a property-focused insurance
Sell now or wait?
A simple question; however, there are many variables to consider. The following questions
can help you evaluate whether or not now is the right time to sell:
• Where do I think the capital gains tax rate is going to be in a few years?
The capital gains tax rate, currently 15%, is in effect through 2010; thereafter, it is likely to
increase to an amount in excess of 20%. For every $10 million in taxable proceeds, this
increase would amount to an extra $500,000 in taxes if a sale were delayed to after 2010. If
an owner is already planning to sell, it would be advisable to begin preparing now in order to
allow for six months to a year to go through the sale process and maximize the proceeds
subject to the current capital gains rates.
• What stage in my work/life cycle am I currently in?
All things being equal, an acquirer will place a higher value on a firm whose
owners/producers are relatively young. Rightly or wrongly, acquirers tend to assume that
owners who are in their late 50s or older will retire or reduce their involvement with the
If you are looking to maximize the value of your business, sell before the owner(s) hit this
age period. The acquirer will be more confident that the ownership group will stick around
and help retain and grow the business post-acquisition.
• Do I have a strong management bench? Are all the owners on the same page with
regard to an exit strategy?
When evaluating an acquisition, an acquirer would ideally like to see that there are multiple
“go-to” people within that firm, rather than just one person. If you do not have a
management team or second-in-command person who could take over seamlessly for you if
you were to discontinue involvement in the business, then it would be wise to develop or
hire people who can fill those roles.
Continuing on the same path, if there are multiple owners within your firm, you will want to
make sure that everyone is in agreement as to the eventual exit strategy. You do not want
to “head to the altar” with an acquirer only to find out that a shareholder or group of
colleagues will be blocking a sale.
• Is the firm’s corporate structure tax-efficient for a sale?
If your firm is an S corporation or limited liability company (LLC), then you are already well
positioned for a sale. If your firm is a C corporation, however, you may want to think about
converting to an S corporation due to the tax ramifications of a sale. All things being equal,
acquirers place a lower value on the stock of a C corporation because they are not able to
derive the tax benefits they could get with amortizing an asset purchase.
In most cases, a converted entity must be an S corporation for 10 years in order to receive
the full tax benefit of the corporate structure. As a seller, if you sell the assets of a C
corporation, you will be hit with double taxation on the proceeds. There are a few instances
where a transaction can be structured as a personal goodwill acquisition in order to
minimize the tax hit. Consulting now with your accountant will help you prepare for when the
time is right to sell.
As mentioned earlier, the decision to sell is dependent on the owner(s)’ personal situation
and goals. If you plan to sell in the next few years, it may be advisable to begin the process
now so that you can take advantage of the low capital gains tax rate. The sale process can
take anywhere from six months to a year when taking into account the various steps
involved (i.e., gathering financials and book of business information, preparing a firm
overview, contacting and meeting with potential acquirers, negotiating an offer, due
diligence, and finalizing legal documentation). Even if you are not currently interested in
exploring a sale, it does not hurt to ponder the previous questions so that you can put
yourself in a favorable position when the time is right.
* Disclosure: Mystic Capital Advisors Group, LLC, was an advisor in this transaction.
Allen M. Go, CFA, is director at Mystic Capital Advisors Group, LLC, an insurance industryfocused investment banking advisory firm, www.mysticcapital.com