Insurance Investment Banking

Sound Advice Results

20.2x ➝ 12.8x EBITDA · mean public broker multiple · Jan 2025 to Apr 2026

Broker multiples compressed. Still a strong time to sell.

Featured Transactions

The Premier Strategic & Value Creating Advisory Firm

Mystic Capital Advisors Group provides a wide array of world-class investment banking and strategic financial advisory services to the retail insurance, specialty insurance, and financial services industry.

Insurance Sector Expertise

We provide comprehensive expertise in developing, evaluating, and executing strategic transactions such as mergers & acquisitions, the carve-out of business units, exits, recapitalizations, reverse mergers, shareholder disputes, strategic partnerships, and restructuring.

1,000+ Transactions

For over 25 years, Mystic Capital has been chosen repeatedly by numerous client CEO’s and Board of Directors of some of the largest, most prominent insurance companies in the world to guide their organizations through transformational situations.

Over 100 Years Of Experience

As a group with over 100 years of combined industry experience, global reach, and extensive networks of professionals worldwide, we are uniquely positioned to help leaders navigate today’s complex and evolving business environment.

Mystic Capital provided expert and personal representation to us, which included credible relationships with potential buyers, thorough evaluation of the finances and value of our agency, strong but realistic contract negotiation, problem solving with a positive attitude and patience with our many questions about the sale process. Mystic was a wonderful advocate for our interests and achieved great results.

Remy Fagan - President & CEOFagan & Michaud Insurance Agency

In the fast paced insurance brokerage environment of today, the professionals of Mystic Capital have been able to provide the analysis and valuation services to keep Hylant Group on the cutting edge of the industry. Their experience in the insurance marketplace along with their responsiveness and dedication has been integral to our growth and success.

Bill Pridgeon - Chief Financial OfficerHylant Group

When it comes to acquisition and strategic opportunities, Mystic Capital has become our valued advisor. We focus our energies on running our business, and we rely on their expertise and experience to guide us through. Mystic Capital's industry knowledge, experience, and attention to detail are unparalleled.

Karen Trudel - Chief Operating OfficerGMI Insurance

your team made what could be a very stressful and exhausting process a very smooth – (and at most times) very enjoyable process

Jennifer Trapani - Co-Founder & Chief Underwriting Officer The Redwoods Group